Skip to content
FIT ClinicChiropractic · Colts Neck, NJ
Call or text 848-301-1515Book Your Appointment

Do Hip Impingement Strength Exercises Help More Than Stretching Does?

A woman in her forties rises from a deep kettlebell squat on a dewy backyard lawn at sunrise. (AI-generated image)

Key takeaways

  • Hip impingement strength exercises may help pain more than stretching does.
  • In a randomised trial of adults with hip impingement, a targeted strengthening program beat a stretching program on pain.

Hip impingement strength exercises may help pain more than stretching does. In a randomised trial of adults with hip impingement, a targeted strengthening program beat a stretching program on pain. The strength group also built stronger hips. Quality of life improved about equally in both groups. The useful first step is an exam that sorts the joint from a muscle or the back.

What is hip impingement, and why does stretching feel like the fix?

Hip impingement is abnormal early contact between the thigh bone and the socket rim as the hip moves. The labrum, the ring of cartilage around the socket, sits right at that rim. Stretching feels like the fix because the hip feels tight, but tightness is the symptom, not the mechanism. Picture the drive home from a long game. You stand up in the driveway and the front of the hip catches. You pull your knee to your chest. It feels tight, so you try harder. You have already done this more times than you can count. Weeks go by, and the pinch is still there when you sit or squat.

Here is the real problem. People often treat the word as a diagnosis. The word impingement describes a shape and a symptom, and those are not the same thing. The Warwick Agreement, an international consensus endorsed by 25 clinical societies, set the definition most clinicians use. It describes FAI syndrome as a triad of symptoms, clinical signs and imaging findings. Its primary symptom is motion-related or position-related pain in the hip or groin. A bony shape alone does not make the syndrome. In a systematic review of volunteers with no hip pain, 37 percent had a cam shape on imaging.

This is not a rare complaint. According to La Trobe University, FAI syndrome affects up to 40 percent of young adults with hip pain. Stiffness is not the injury; it is the message. The question is what the message is about, and a stretch cannot answer that.

Do hip impingement strength exercises work better than stretching?

For pain and hip strength, in one well-run trial, yes. For overall hip-related quality of life, the two approaches came out about even. The PhysioFIRST study from La Trobe University followed 154 people with FAI syndrome for six months. Participants were aged 18 to 50 and randomly assigned to targeted strengthening or standardised stretching. People in the strength group were 2.3 times more likely to report improved pain and gained more hip strength.

Both groups ended up improving hip-related quality of life by about twice the minimal clinically important change. So if you have been stretching for months, your effort was not wasted. The strength group simply added something on top: better pain and stronger hips. The lead researcher, Joanne Kemp, said the strength gain “could matter for long-term recovery”. That is a researcher hedging honestly, and so should we.

What the strengthening looked like

The stretching group did generalised hip and lower limb stretching, varied weekly on a set programme. The strengthening approach, described in the pilot trial, was individual and progressive. It had four components:

Notice the word targeted. Nobody handed out the same sheet of exercises to everyone. Each program started from what that person’s hip could and could not do.

Is the pinch coming from the hip joint, a muscle or your back?

That is the question an exam answers, and it is why the exam comes before any plan at FIT Clinic. Dr. Michael Brandon, DC, puts it to new patients plainly: “I explain the options and tell them I don’t actually know what they need yet — I need to go over the exam first.”

His exam starts from three questions: “What is their pain, where is their pain, and what motions or activities cause it.” Each one does sorting work. What the pain is separates a pinch from a dull ache, or from tingling that travels. Where it is separates the front of the groin from the side of the hip, the buttock or the low back. Which motions cause it separates sitting and deep flexion from stairs, running, or getting out of a car. Small details count. A wider stance with the feet turned out may change the pinch in a squat. So may the pelvis sitting tipped forward in an anterior pelvic tilt. The answers point toward the joint, a muscle or the back. You can read more on our hip pain page.

Sometimes the answer is that FIT Clinic is not the right fit. Dr. Brandon is direct about that too: “If I can’t be the one to help them, I want to at least put them in the right direction to find someone who can.” If the hip is older and the stiffness looks more like wear, that is a different conversation, covered in our post on hip arthritis exercise.

Why should hip strength be measured instead of guessed?

Because the benefit in the trial came with measurably stronger hips. You cannot know whether yours are getting stronger without a number. Feeling stronger and being stronger are two different things. The working rule in our building is short: if you aren’t testing, you’re guessing.

I coached strength and conditioning for the Toronto Blue Jays, the Tampa Bay Buccaneers and the University of South Florida. Later I worked with athlete-management systems, force plates, motion capture and wearables. None of that equipment matters on its own. What actually matters is the habit it forces: take a baseline, do the work, test again.

FIT Clinic shares its building with FIT Lab, where strength and recovery are measured rather than guessed. The FIT Age Reveal starts with an ARX strength baseline, grip strength and sit-to-rise. It adds a 3D body-composition scan, a VO2 estimate and an HRV snapshot. Sit-to-rise is the plain test of getting down to the floor and back up. For a hip that pinches, a baseline turns “I think it’s better” into something you can check.

How do you keep the hip range a stretch gives you?

You keep range by building strength inside it, which is the idea behind FIT Stretch. A stretch can open a position for the moment. Strength is what lets you own that position the next time you squat, sit low or reach the ground.

FIT Stretch is one-on-one assisted stretching in Colts Neck. We find where you’re tight, stretch you further than you can alone, and build the strength to keep it. The honest caveat: the PhysioFIRST trial compared strengthening with stretching. It did not test the two together, so the trial cannot tell you what the combination adds.

What it does tell you is that stretching by itself left pain and strength gains on the table. If your current routine is all stretching, the step the evidence points to is to add strength. If you are not sure where to start, that is what the exam is for. We wrote more about keeping the range a stretch gives you if flexibility is part of your goal.

Can hip impingement affect running and walking?

It can, if running or walking is one of the motions that brings the pinch on. That is exactly the third exam question, so it gets tested rather than assumed. Some people feel it in deep flexion, like a low squat, and not on a run at all. Others feel it at the end of the stride, when the leg trails behind them.

If you want better hip extension for running, the pilot program offers a clue. Its first strengthening exercise was prone hip extension: a gluteal squeeze, then lifting the leg behind you. Whether that changes your stride is a question for the force plate and the stopwatch, not for a guess.

Can walking strengthen hip muscles? Walking is good for your body, and if it does not provoke the pinch, keep doing it. It is not, however, the program that was tested. The pilot trial used supervised, regular gym-based strengthening for the hip and trunk, with load that progressed over time. Dr. Brandon notes that “Athletes are usually much more motivated than the average person to get better,” which helps when the work is progressive. For runners and players, the FIT Sports Evaluation is a short appointment built around exactly this kind of question.

Frequently asked questions

Does a cam shape on my X-ray mean I need surgery?

Not on its own. Population studies find cam shapes in between 7.3 and 38.2 percent of adults, many with no symptoms. Surgery is a real option for some people. A meta-analysis of randomised trials found arthroscopy gave better early patient-reported outcomes than targeted physiotherapy. That decision belongs with an orthopaedic surgeon, after an exam and a trial of care.

Should I stop stretching my hip completely?

Not necessarily. In the PhysioFIRST trial, the stretching group also improved, and neither group had adverse events. Stretching is a reasonable part of a plan. The evidence simply favours targeted strength alongside it. Treat stretching as one tool, not the whole kit.

How long does hip impingement take to heal?

There is no single timeline, and the trial measured improvement rather than healing. PhysioFIRST participants had six physiotherapy consultations and 12 supervised sessions in the first three months. Then they continued in a gym. Rest alone was not part of either program. Outcomes were judged at six months, which is a fair horizon for strength work to show up.

Is hip impingement the same as hip arthritis?

No. Impingement is about the shape of the joint and pain with certain motions, usually in younger, active adults. Cam shapes are most common in young active men, and pincer shapes in middle-aged women. Arthritis is wear of the joint surface, and the exercise conversation is different.

Is a chiropractor a reasonable first stop for a pinchy hip?

It can be, if the first visit is an exam rather than a treatment. At FIT Clinic the exam sorts the joint from a muscle or the back before anyone talks about care. Dr. Brandon is clear that forceful cracking is not the point: “You don’t need to ‘crack’ or give that large adjustment to people.”

The Bottom Line

If you have been stretching a pinchy hip with no result, the evidence points to a different next step. Targeted strength work may help reduce pain, and stretching alone may leave that gain on the table. The order matters. Start with the exam. Find out what the pain is, where it is and which motions cause it. Then measure your strength, work through a plan built to address it, and test again.

Book an exam at FIT Clinic, 8 Merchants Way, Colts Neck, or call or text (848) 301-1515. If you drive in from Middletown, Holmdel or Freehold, look for the corner of Route 34 and County Route 537. Parking is free in front of and behind the building. Nothing happens without your OK, and you decide what happens next.

Book your first visit at https://fitclinic.co/book/ — or call or text 848-301-1515.

FIT Clinic at Functionised — 8 Merchants Way, Colts Neck, NJ 07722.

Near you

Location
FIT Clinic, 8 Merchants Way, Colts Neck, NJ, 07722, (848) 301-1515

Directions

Sources

Get The Thrive Letter. One short email from Jim every Thursday: one idea, one 60-second fix you can feel, and what to do next. Unsubscribe any time.



FIT Clinic · 8 Merchants Way, Colts Neck, NJ 07722 · 848-301-1515. We never share your email.

More from Learn